Top | Jennifer Meier — Blog

Tomato Pie

(post, Jennifer Meier)

primary-image, l

In hindsight, I can trace my tomato pie disaster back to two things. One, I am not Southern. I am however, Southern-curious, which is what led me to attempt tomato pie in the first place. It just sounded so perfect…a pie made entirely from ripe, red tomatoes covered with a bubbling layer of cheese and a soft biscuit crust. I imagined myself baking it while wearing a summer dress and a flowered apron that fluttered with the breeze wafting in through an open kitchen window. I would serve it on my sprawling porch to ladies who came over in the afternoon for sweet tea. 

Why I thought a recipe that included a cup of mayonnaise mixed with cheddar cheese would transport me to such an ethereal place, I’m not sure (I don't even own a flowered apron). I should’ve known from experience that my elaborate culinary daydreams often lead to disappointment. But the pictures I kept finding of tomato pie were irresistible. Which leads me to the second thing responsible for my tomato pie disaster. 

There’s an awful lot of trickery going on out there in food magazines and websites. Just like celebrity bodies are airbrushed into perfection, so it seems is the food we eat. Recipes mentioned that the tomatoes in the pie might be a tad watery but I wasn’t worried. After all, every photo showed a tomato pie held together beautifully; firm layers of tomatoes and a browned, bubbling layer of cheese and mayo. Maybe no one else will tell you this but I will: Those photos are lies. All lies. 

My first tomato pie was a soggy mess of mushy tomatoes and undercooked onions drowning in an oozing layer of cheese and mayo that tasted exactly like putting a spoon into a jar of Hellmann’s. I turned the pie on its side and tomato water poured out. Calling this attempt a disaster may seem overly dramatic. But at the time, it felt like one. I threw the pie away before there were any witnesses. 

I waited a month to try again, until the middle of summer when I knew tomatoes were at their ripest. I stopped thinking of tomato pie as a Southern dish and started thinking about it as a West Coast interpretation of a Southern dish.  I used Early Girl tomatoes and roasted them until they were sweet and less moist. I used fresh basil instead of dried and leeks instead of onions. I subbed out the mayo and cheddar for crème fraiche and fresh mozzarella. Instead of a biscuit crust on top, I gave the pie a final dose of West Coast flavor by covering it with Vella Dry Jack cheese 

My recipe for tomato pie takes it far from its Southern roots. A purist might not like it. But for this West Coast girl, it was the tomato pie I’d been dreaming of all along. 

West Coast Tomato Pie with Crème Fraiche and Mozzarella

One 9-inch pie crust
3 pounds ripe tomatoes
1 tablespoon olive oil
1/2 teaspoon Maldon sea salt
1/4 teaspoon black pepper
2 small leeks or 1 large leek, thinly sliced 
3/4 cup roughly chopped fresh basil
1 1/2 cups grated mozzarella
1/2 cup crème fraiche
1 cup grated Dry Jack cheese 

Preheat oven to 375

Slice tomatoes in half and gently squeeze most of the seeds out. Cut the tomatoes into 1/2-inch slices. Put them in a large bowl and toss with olive oil, salt and pepper. In a shallow baking pan lined with parchment, roast the tomatoes for 1 hour. 

While the tomatoes are roasting: 

Prick the pie crust all over the bottom with a fork and pre-bake it in the oven for 10-15 minutes. Remove and let cool.

Sauté the leeks in a drizzle of olive oil until soft and lightly browned. Set aside. 

Mix the crème fraiche with the mozzarella. Set aside. (If using fresh mozzarella, freeze it for an hour and it will be easier to grate)

When the tomatoes have cooked for an hour, remove them from the oven and drain off any liquid. Return the tomatoes to a large bowl and mix in basil and leeks. Put the tomatoes in the pie shell. Cover with a layer of the crème fraiche and mozzarella. Sprinkle the Dry Jack cheese on top. 

Bake for 45 minutes until the top is browned. Resist all urges to cut into the pie until it is completely cooled.